I FOUGHT THE LAW
One Rider leads Lonely Crusade Against Helmets
by Ross Crockford
Monday Magazine April 15-21,1999 Volume 25 Issue 15
"I try to consume as little as possible," says Victoria cyclist
Bill Wilson. "That's why I'm into cycling in the first place. I try
to do things as simply as possible."
For Wilson, that simplicity also entails not wearing a bicycle
helmet - a longstanding practice which has helped him get to know
his way around Victoria's courthouse. Just hours after B.C.'s
helmet regulations came into effect in 1996, Wilson was given the
dubious honour of being the first person in Victoria to be issued
a $29 ticket for failing to wear his headgear. He's received seven
more tickets since then, and he's disputed every single one of
them.
"It's a way for the government to get out of doing real things for
cyclists," says Wilson of the helmet regs. "The government treats
helmets as the be-all and end-all for bicycle safety. I'd like them
to work on the real safety issues." In Europe, he points out there
are no requirements to wear helmets and yet they haven't noticed
huge numbers of head injuries. "The helmet law hasn't worked.
Where's the 88% drop in serious head injury [B.C.'s] helmet
lobbyists predicted?
Wilson also dislikes helmets because he thinks they discourage
people from riding bikes, an argument which is often advanced by
cycling groups whenever helmet laws are introduced in a new
jurisdiction. But Victoria's cycling groups haven't exactly thrown
their support behind him. Says John Luton, president of the Greater
Victoria Cycling Coalition: "It may be noble fighting against Big
Brother, but we've moved on."
So Wilson goes it alone. So far, of his eight tickets, four have
been either withdrawn by Crown prosecutors or thrown out because
the arresting officers either didn't show up; three haven't gone to
court yet. Wilson's lost only one case, and for that he paid a $10
fine.
And even that he would've appealed on constitutional
grounds--arguing, in part, that the law infringed upon his freedom
to practice the religious values of simple living--until he
discovered that printing a transcript of his trial would've cost
$400. "It was easier for me just to wait for the next ticket," says
Wilson.
Reprinted with permission of Monday Magazine